Category: Software Development

In the final tips post of the year, lets address a solution to a problem that most websites face once they have been online for a while.

If you have a back-office or the concept of user accounts, soon you will face the security problem of attackers trying to hack into these private zones of the website.

These attackers can either be people trying to login as somebody else, or even bots trying to find accounts with common/leaked passwords.

Unfortunately we cannot rely on users to pick strong and unique passwords. We can help them, as I explained in a previous post, but it isn’t guaranteed that the user will make a good choice.

Using a slow key derivation function, to slowdown the process and increase the time required to test an high number of possibilities, helps but isn’t enough.

However we can go even further with this strategy, by controlling the number of attempts and only allowing a “given number of tries per time window”.

This is very easy to achieve on Django projects by relying on the django-axes package. Here’s an explanation of what it does:

Axes records login attempts to your Django powered site and prevents attackers from attempting further logins to your site when they exceed the configured attempt limit.

django-axes documentation

Basically you end up with record of attempts (that you can see in the admin) and allows you to define how the system will behave after multiple failed tries, by setting the maximum number of failures and cool-off periods.

You can check the package here, it is very easy to setup and it shouldn’t require many changes to your code. The documentation can be found here and it covers everything you will need so I won’t provide any examples this time.

I hope this tip ends up being useful and wish you a Merry Christmas. The tips will continue in 2022.

This time I’m gonna address Django’s builtin authentication system, more specifically the ways we can build custom improvements over the already very solid foundations it provides.

The idea for this post came from reading an article summing up some considerations we should have when dealing with passwords. Most of those considerations are about what controls to implement (what “types” of passwords to accept) and how to securely store those passwords. By default Django does the following:

• Passwords are stored using PBKDF2. There are also other alternatives such as Argon2 and bcrypt, that can be defined in the setting PASSWORD_HASHERS.
• Every Django release the “strength”/cost of this algorithm is increased. For example, version 3.1 applied 216000 iterations and the last version (3.2 at the time of writing) applies 260000. The migration from one to another is done automatically once the user logs in.
• There are a set of validators that control the kinds of passwords allowed to be used in the system, such as enforcing a minimum length. These validators are defined on the setting AUTH_PASSWORD_VALIDATORS.

By default when we start a new project these are the included validators :

• UserAttributeSimilarityValidator
• MinimumLengthValidator
• CommonPasswordValidator
• NumericPasswordValidator

The names are very descriptive and I would say a good starting point. But as the article mentions the next step is to make sure users aren’t reusing previously breached passwords or using passwords that are known to be easily guessed (even when complying with the other rules). CommonPasswordValidator already does part of this job but with a very limited list (20000 entries).

Improving password validation

So for the rest of this post I will show you some ideas on how we can make this even better. More precisely, prevent users from using a known weak password.

1. Use your own list

The easiest approach, but also the more limited one, is providing your own list to `CommonPasswordValidator`, containing more entries than the ones provided by default. The list must be provided as a file with one entry in lower case per line. It can be set like this:

{
  "NAME": "django.contrib.auth.password_validation.CommonPasswordValidator",
  "OPTIONS": {"password_list_path": "<path_to_your_file>"}
}

2. Use zxcvbn-python

Another approach is to use an existing and well-known library that evaluates the password, compares it with a list of known passwords (30000) but also takes into account slight variations and common patterns.

To use zxcvbn-python we need to implement our own validator, something that isn’t hard and can be done this way:

# <your_app>/validators.py

from django.core.exceptions import ValidationError
from zxcvbn import zxcvbn


class ZxcvbnValidator:
    def __init__(self, min_score=3):
        self.min_score = min_score

    def validate(self, password, user=None):
        user_info = []
        if user:
            user_info = [
                user.email, 
                user.first_name, 
                user.last_name, 
                user.username
            ]
        result = zxcvbn(password, user_inputs=user_info)

        if result.get("score") < self.min_score:
            raise ValidationError(
                "This passoword is too weak",
                code="not_strong_enough",
                params={"min_score": self.min_score},
            )

    def get_help_text(self):
        return "The password must be long and not obvious"

Then we just need to add to the settings just like the other validators. It’s an improvement but we still can do better.

3. Use “have i been pwned?”

As suggested by the article, a good approach is to make use of the biggest source of leaked passwords we have available, haveibeenpwned.com.

The full list is available for download, but I find it hard to justify a 12GiB dependency on most projects. The alternative is to use their API (documentation available here), but again we must build our own validator.

# <your_app>/validators.py

from hashlib import sha1
from io import StringIO

from django.core.exceptions import ValidationError

import requests
from requests.exceptions import RequestException

class LeakedPasswordValidator:
    def validate(self, password, user=None):
        hasher = sha1(password.encode("utf-8"))
        hash = hasher.hexdigest().upper()
        url = "https://api.pwnedpasswords.com/range/"

        try:
            resp = requests.get(f"{url}{hash[:5]}")
            resp.raise_for_status()
        except RequestException:
            raise ValidationError(
                "Unable to evaluate password.",
                code="network_failure",
            )

        lines = StringIO(resp.text).readlines()
        for line in lines:
            suffix = line.split(":")[0]

            if hash == f"{hash[:5]}{suffix}":
                raise ValidationError(
                    "This password has been leaked before",
                    code="leaked_password",
                )

    def get_help_text(self):
        return "Use a different password"

Then add it to the settings.

Edit: As suggested by one reader, instead of this custom implementation we could use pwned-passwords-django (which does practically the same thing).

And for today this is it. If you have any suggestions for other improvements related to this matter, please share them in the comments, I would like to hear about them.